2010年1月16日星期六

Reflection on "Prison may not be a perfect solution, but it's all we have"

The New York Times
January 16, 2010
Prison may not be a perfect solution, but it's all we have http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/politics/lawandorder/7004829/Prison-may-not-be-a-perfect-solution-but-its-all-we-have.html
Group: Girls & Hill
Name: Li Ruixue(Rachel)

The House of Commons Justice Committee of UK has published its first report, in which it insisted that increasing the number of prisons in the past decade was a mistake and the government should have devoted the resources to alternative methods of rehabilitation. The author found the report very feeble.
The report said that UK imprisoned more of its population than some other European countries. However it ignored the fact that UK had an extremely high crime rate and UK actually imprisoned a lower proportion of convicts than some adjacent countries. The author pointed out that some statics used in the report didn’t have a reasonable connection with the conclusion. Moreover, the author believed that prison was the most effective way of preventing further crime because prisoners could not reoffend. In the end, the author indicated that the committee did not really know what they were talking about and showed contempt for the public.
The author’s analysis and argument make sense to me. Prison may not necessarily reform convicts, but it protects innocent people, deters some potential criminals from committing a crime and serves as a kind of punishment. I think the increasing prison population is a consequence instead of a choice of the government. The report insisted that it would be far better if the number in prison had dropped dramatically. However those who deserve to be imprisoned shouldn’t be given the chance to escape punishment just in order to reduce the prison population.
However, the increasing prison population should still be paid attention to. Prevention of crimes and rehabilitation are also important. The government should be responsible for its people. It is not fair of the government to do little to the causes of high crime rate and only punish people after they’ve broken the law. Some people in prison deserve to be given a second chance.

6 条评论:

  1. I agree with your point that the aim of imprisonment is not only to reform the convicts. It also protect innocent people. Therefore, the government cannot simply reduce the number of prisons and use the resources for other methods. I think the more effective way is to prevent crime rather than clearing up the mess after a crime. High crime rate is the main cause for this question. So, the government should pay more attention on this issure. It is an more efficient method to cut down the number of prisons.

    回复删除
  2. It is true that the prison had a strong effect on reducing crime rate, but the increasing number of prisoners should also be concerned seriously. We can hardly imagine how large the payout is to support such a prison. It is a huge amount of money. The condition in prison sometimes is better than a poor man’s home. It is true that some people are deserved to be in prison but may I ask do they deserve the comfort? The prison is actually a big free hotel for the criminals. And who will support it? It is the innocent and hardworking citizens. It is clear that the plan of rehabilitation cannot be done easily, but it does not mean that we should not try. The prison may be the only way now, but it should not be forever. The reducing of prisoner should be done as quickly as possible or too many prisoners will bring both financial and social burdens to society.

    By Brandy

    回复删除
  3. I think you made a good summary and decribe the whole problem clearly. Besides, I agree with that judging the policy whether it is a mistake should not only depends on the imprisoned population but also should be relied to the proportion fo convicts. On the other hand, you think the goverment should not let the criminals excape from the pulishment which they deserve, just because of the big imprisoned population, which I think it is completely right and is the main point of this problem.

    BY KEVIN DEMO

    回复删除
  4. I agree that prison is to reform convicts and protect the public. I think prison is a warning to people. If the government simply reduces the prison population regardless of the high crime rate, it can be said that laws become less strict, which probably increases the crime rate finally. Also, there is a question: dose the prison really function? We can see that some people can be in and out of prison just in few years. Doesn’t it indicate the invalidation of the prison? Therefore, instead of just reducing the prison population, laws should be more perfect and stricter; people should be more educated so that there will less crimes; also, prison should really work so that people released from prison will not be put in it once again.

    by Yvonne (Shi Yuanyuan)

    回复删除
  5. Haha, more prisons in UK?! To be honest, I will be expecting no more than a prison guards strike, then guards and prisoners will have “break” together~~ lol =D

    More prisons in UK, dudes? Do u guys really know how much effort does UK government pay on prisons? Not mention the facilities; they’ve got a huge group of stuff in each prison, such as prison officers, offender supervisors, personal officers, probation officers, psychologists, chaplains, education and workshop stuff, health care stuff, CARAT workers, and so so on. The government even arranges “Official prison visitors” who are paid to visit prisoners who have not many people to visit them!! Besides the great num of prison stuff, welfare of the stuff is considerable as well: salary, annual leave, pension, training, flexible working hours, Work Life Balance, Season ticket advance…
    Alright, these are the UK gov.’s investment.
    Then, what’s the interest, or say, profit?
    Answer: ZERO
    When more labor resource becomes prison population, the gov. will have to say: “Oh, sry, we’ve got no money to sustain ur welfare…” then, there comes the strike – the repertory of UK man.

    by Draco

    回复删除
  6. "Prison may not be a perfect solution, but it's all we have"--the committee should be praised for their honesty. It's quite hard to solve the problem with normal methods in a place where crime is part of the culture.

    Prison, however, is a protection more than a solution. No matter what we have to do with the number of the prisons, there's one thing remain unchanged, what we send in are still who harms the other citizens and break the law. If there is a need of adding more prisons, then fulfil the need. How to low down the rate of crime is another problem.
    By Francois

    回复删除