2010年1月15日星期五

Reflection on Reid regrets “negro” remarks

Staits Times
Jan 10, 2010
Reid regrets “negro” remarks----APF
http://www.straitstimes.com/BreakingNews/World/Story/STIStory_475582.html
Group: Girls and hill
Name: Yang Yu ( Elika)


US senator Harry Reid apologized for his racial comments about President Barak Obama’s election and Obama accepted it.

Here I would like to divide my reflections into the following three aspects.

First of all, it indicates racial discrimination is still a serious problem that US has never resolved thoroughly since its founding. It has been decades of years since civil war, the period when Martin Luther King was denoted as a hero for his trying to demand equal rights for black people. However, research shows there is huge difference between the living conditions and employment status of the colored people and the white, and thirty percent people admit they have racial prejudice. There is even no exception for president Obama, who is the first Africa-American president. He was commented “light skinned” and “with no Negro dialect, unless he wanted to have one” for his election.

On the one hand, Obama apparently shouldn’t get these injustice racial comments. Is that he is the unprecedented black skinned president the reason contributes to more disputes, or is it just the presidents are always being judged? On the other hand, Reid’s comments reflect what many Americans think of unconsciously and instinctively to some degree. It cannot be asserted that racial discrimination is deeply ingrained. The election of Obama is a milestone that shows the changes. Why he is popular among the voters also reflect the current situation. What President Obama does on his position will also affect this country.

Secondly, I would like to discuss the event itself, making unfavorable comments about government leaders, or said offend. Reid was later called on to step down for his remarks, but we can tell it was more like the result of a Party struggle. Let’s see, what will happen if it is in countries like Singapore or China? There was literary persecution in the olden times, and there is strict censorship in the present age. What are the consequences of civilians’ offence to government officials in China? Most people know the fact but it is even not wise to talk over.

In US, the presidents, the Congress and the elections are always the subject of innuendo in many fields, cartoons, movies, novels etceteras. It seems people are free to joke about them, or perhaps when not raise touchy subjects. In this country where the freedom of speech is of great importance, are the consequences serious for offending the president? Joe Wilson who yelled “you lie” to Obama, and this time Reid, they both apologized to the president after offence and were forcing to step down. Besides, they became very famous of course.

Thirdly, is Obama a good president? He was violated as a person and also a president. Did the President accept their apologies as a president or as an individual? Obama is popular among the voters mainly because he is close to people and his personal charm. He urges economy reforms to save the economic crisis and puts forward health care plan to lighten citizens’ burden but confronted with great resistance. On the contrary, some people think he should solve the problem of using crude oil and clear all the nuclear weapons as a good president. As an outsider, I cannot tell if he is a good president for US or not, I can only say he is trying hard to do the “changes”, but he is too eager and his plans and reforms are too massive that he cannot achieve his goal instantly because the country may be not capable enough to go through these changes.

1 条评论:

  1. In my own opinion, the racial discrimination can hardly be eliminated completely, what are people trying to do is just deminish the prejudice. Take us for example, can you say that you are able to treat all the people equally? I think cannot, even though we are not willing to treat people of different colors unequally. So I think even in Singapore, the multi-racial society, or America, the so-called melt pot, this kind of phenomenon is still existing, but not so obvious, or let's say, not sooo unequal; cause people are putting their effort to build a harmonious society, to make the whole country a big family.

    And secondly, the slogen that Obama made when he was competing for the place of president is "change". And now, it is the time to make his promise come true. I agree that the society does need changes, but sometimes it just cannot be that aggresive; because changes need time. After all, Rome wasn't built in one day. And we cannot simply say that these changes are good or not. I think only time can tell everything and history will give the right comments to the changes.

    Helen

    回复删除