2010年1月16日星期六

Reflection on “Facing End-of-Life Talks, Doctors Choose to Wait”

The New York Times
January 11, 2010
Facing End-of-Life Talks, Doctors Choose to Wait – APF
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/12/health/12seco.html?ref=science
Group: Girls & Hill
Name: Shi Yuanyuan (Yvonne)

Guidelines for doctors say that end-of-life talks should begin when a patient has a year or less to live so that patients and their families can plan whether they want to do everything possible to stay alive or to avoid wind up dying in the hospital. But most doctors prefer to postpone those conversations until the patients feel worse or there are no more treatments to offer.

From my point of view, the early end-of-life talks are essential.

For patients, they have the right to know the truth and to make the decision. Actually, it is not rare to see that after suffering several months’ terrible and painful radiation and chemotherapy, patients still go to the other world in the end. However, if they could know their situation earlier, they could make a different choice. They could spend the rest of their life more meanful instead of wasting their precious time facing various kinds of machines. They could be happy and optimistic with their families rather than becoming more and more disappointed and depressed from the endless unbearable treatments. Also, if patients are told the truth when they have no more time, it is quite difficult for them to accept that. Although I am an outsider, I suppose nobody is willing to die in the hospital with his or her body connected to all kinds of tubes and machines.

For doctors, when they know someone is going to die of their desease, it is only fair to help the patients understand that. What’s more, I think good doctors should not only take care of the patients' body but also pay attention to their psychological state as well. Doctors should be trained to improve the communication skills as the patients need to know the real truth and remain a positive attitude towards their life at the same time.

6 条评论:

  1. In general I agree with you that patients should know the truth until there’s no choice or time left. However, I can understand doctors' postponing those talks because it is quite difficult to ascertain whether the patient will surely die or not. Miracles sometimes do happen if the patient does not give up. It is also extremely difficult to estimate the lifespan left. For those who are not mentally strong enough, the announcement of death may make them lose hope and shorten their life. Desperate patients may even commit suicide sometimes. So it is reasonable for a doctor to put off the conversion until they have to talk to the patients about death. Some people would rather not hear it until they die. But for some people, they may give up treatment after the bad news but they will not give up life. They will hold a positive attitude and treasure the life left. Miracles happen to these people more often.

    Rachel(Li Ruixue)

    回复删除
  2. I strongly agree with you on this problem.
    For a patient,no matter how serious the his disease is, he should have the right to know the truth about his own life and to make a choice whether to accept the treatment or not. If a patient is made sure that he only has one year left, he may use this precious time to do something he likes to do or make his dream come true, which may bring him a better mood and has a positive effect on his health. For the patient's family, an endless and useless treatment for a dying person sometimes is a suffering for them, not only on the aspect of finance, but also on the aspect of mental states. They love their family member so much that they cannot stand the painful treatment the patient experienced. For some families, compared with making their relative stay longer in pain, it is a better choice to make their relative have a happy and meaningful ending of life. Of course, as you said, doctors should pay attention on their way of talking to dying patients, because they are usually very sensitive and vulnerable.

    by Crystal

    回复删除
  3. I agree with you that it should really depend on the patients. For those patients who are terminally ill, despite what doctors may suggest, I think the decisions for them are tough. Although most of the patients are clearly aware of the end of cancer, whether being told or not could make a difference. Obviously, optimists and pessimists react differently. Besides, just like what you've mentioned, the way doctors tell the patients is also important. Under these circumstances, the propective "countdown" will scarcely be precise. Therefore, patients shouldn't be so credulous. Anyway, try to be optimistic and never give up cos` miracles are on the way!!

    回复删除
  4. I agree with the thread starter's view.Different people suit to different ways. optimistic and brave people can face the reality. They may chose to fight with the destiny until the end of their life or they may chose to apend their limited lifetime to acomplish something they most want to do. For these people, it's not bad to have their last talk earlier. On the contrary, for people more fragile and sensitive, it's more suitable to keep them in the dark because once they are exposed to the fact, it may worsen their state. That's not concerning the right, but only a white lie.
    Besides, how the doctor act is the most important. They should take the patients' condition into consideration and make a a wise decision. From another perspective, we should think over the reasons why doctors prefer to do the last talk later. Firstly, that may be because they believe most people are the latter ones and it's good for their therapy if they are not concerned. Sencondly, some doctors want to make more profits from the patients so they keep them stay in hospital and receive expensive cure. When it comes to doctors' bedside manner, I'd like to mantion a social ill. In many hospitals in China especially, doctors always prescribe some expensive medicine, but mostly people find that they are not more effective than the normal ones. Moreover, many doctors act rudely to the patients. Their bedside manners impair patients trust and further affect the healing effect.

    回复删除
  5. The above posted by Yang Yu( Erika)

    回复删除
  6. I think the end-of-life talk is not necessary only when the patient is feeling worse and worse. And the attitude the most doctors hold, waiting , is reasonable.

    The duty of the doctor is to save lives, even if there is little hope. Life shold never been forsaken easily. Both the doctor and patient should strive to the last minute. That is why patients want to receive painful and sometimes helpless treatment.
    If the doctor give them the end-of-life talk, it will be a big strike on their mentality. Strong mind is the most important thing that a patient need to have if he wants to recover. After the talk, I'm sure many of the patients will break down and end their lives earlier and no miracle will occur. Doctor can never affirm what will happen next. Life is full of the unknown.

    By Brian

    回复删除