2010年1月28日星期四

Comment on ST Forum article

Source: Strait Time Forum
Title: Full-time mums should enjoy full subsidies too
URL: http://www.straitstimes.com/STForum/OnlineStory/STIStory_482909.html
Group: Girl&Hill
Name: Li Ruixue

I refer to the letter on Jan 28 by Ms Ng Hwee Kiang(Full-time mums should enjoy full subsidies too).

I understand Ms Ng’s worries and difficulties. It is an extremely tough task for a mother to work and raise several children at the same time. Working mothers face a lot of pressure and often have difficulties balancing family and work. Some people don’t want to hire babysitters to look after their children because they are worried about the quality of the service and the influence of babysitters’ behavior on their children. Therefore iff a couple want more children, the mother may need to stay at home. Since the Singapore government encourages parents to have more children, policies should be made to ensure the living standard of the families with more children. But I have to say that this issue should also be considered from other standpoints.

Indeed, non-working mothers may feel it unfair and disappointing to receive half subsidies. However, to be in the working mothers’ shoes, it also seems unfair if full-time mothers also enjoy full subsidies because working mothers not only contribute to increasing the population, but also contribute to increasing Singapore’s GDP at the same time.

Just as “ForeignerTheOnlyHope” has replied, if "Logically, doesn't a single-income family deserve more subsidy than a dual-income one?", then logically, a family with no bread earner should enjoy even higher subsidies. “Those who contribute less get the same”, this is not logical.

The subsidies come from the taxes paid by the working population. Therefore logically, those who pay deserve more money back. In this sense, it is fair for working mums to receive more subsidies than full-time mums.

To make it fair for both working and non-working mothers, I think that the family should be given a certain amount of money for every child, which I think has already been implemented in Singapore. So generally, I think the policies are reasonable. There may be room of improvement, but it is impossible for the government to give everyone the same treatment.

4 条评论:

  1. Practice has show that a woman with income makes a family, or say, a marriage more stable. From this point of view, the policy is still reasonable. Besides, that a mother can be a full-time mother exactly indicates that she has quite a lot of children which can be a great burden in this modern society. In order to give these children equal and nice education, the gov. has the duty to help these families. Nevertheless, the S'pore gov. has made it harder to immigrate in, which indicates a saturation in population, so I guess there will be less policy like this encouraging more birth.

    回复删除
  2. I agree with you that the government policies are quite reasonable and fair to all. Yes, those full-time mothers may feel that they are treated unfairly, while, just as you have mentioned, the subsides are paid by the tax-payers including working mothers. Full subsides to full-time mothers means that working mothers who are living under greater pressure should share their gains with full-time mothers even if they have the same number of children. Obviously, it would be unfair to working mothers. We should say it is the right for mothers to make a decision between their career and family. However, they should afford for their own decisions.What the government should do is to provide a better situation and equal education to each child.


    By: Kyle

    回复删除
  3. Wow, Rachel, your point is quite reasonable, and you express yourself quite clearly~ I really like your style of explanation, which is very persuasive.
    I can accept your point, but differently, I think the subsidies should be given depending on the total family income, not just counting on whether the mothers work or not. For example, I think a working mother with a low salary should have more subsidies than a wealthy full-time mother, but a poor full-time mother should be given more than the working mother, since her family hasn’t got enough income. Those whose total family income is higher ought to get fewer subsidies. However, I also agree that the Singapore government has done a good job.


    (By Puluo)

    回复删除
  4. I strongly agree that both the working mother and non-working mother should be given subsidies. Compared with those who stay at home all day long, working mothers are more diligent, thus they deserve subsidies. Second, those who are not working must already have enough money to raise their child, unless they are fired...in this perspective, those who are working should be given a raise in their salary to ensure their budget for raising their children.

    回复删除